Types of Heat Pumps: Which Is Right for Your Home?

Choosing between the different types of heat pumps is not straightforward: a system that works well in a highly insulated new-build flat may be the wrong choice for an older house. The decision is not simply air-source versus ground-source. Homeowners also need to consider whether they want to heat radiators, circulate warm air or produce hot water, and how much alteration their property can accommodate.

Colin Usher, an architect specialising in low-energy new builds and eco-refurbishments, has lived with a heat pump in his own four-bedroom home for nearly 15 years. His experience with that system and other low-energy properties has made him wary of one-size-fits-all advice.

Colin Usher, low-carbon homes architect

"I would recommend different systems for different situations, to be honest. It's a question of balancing what the building needs against the complexity of the installation."

Colin Usher, Retired architect and low energy house designer

Part of the heat pump ready series

This guide follows on from our nine-part series on preparing your home, produced with low-carbon homes architect Colin Usher.

  1. How to make your home heat pump ready
  2. Assessing your home for heat pumps
  3. Draught proofing your home
  4. Floor and loft insulation
  5. Improving windows and doors
  6. Wall insulation options
  7. Energy-saving technologies
  8. Home batteries
  9. Solar panels and heat pumps

What are the main types of heat pump?

Heat pumps work on the same basic refrigeration cycle as fridges and air conditioning. A refrigerant absorbs low-temperature heat as it evaporates. A compressor raises its pressure and temperature, allowing it to release heat as it condenses. An expansion valve then reduces the pressure so the cycle can begin again. A fridge moves heat out of its cabinet; a heat pump moves heat from an external source into the home.

For most householders, the three main options are:

  • Ground-source heat pumps extract heat from the ground and usually transfer it to a water-based heating system.
  • Air-to-water heat pumps extract heat from outdoor air and transfer it to water circulating through radiators, underfloor heating and, where fitted, a hot-water cylinder.
  • Air-to-air heat pumps extract heat from outdoor air and deliver warmth directly to rooms through indoor units or ducting, rather than a radiator circuit.
Boiler Upgrade Scheme values for England and Wales, as published November 2026. Check current eligibility with your installer and Ofgem.
Type Takes heat from Delivers heat through Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant
Air-to-water Outdoor air Radiators, underfloor heating and hot water £7,500 (£9,000 replacing oil or LPG)
Ground-source The ground Radiators, underfloor heating and hot water £7,500 (£9,000 replacing oil or LPG)
Air-to-air Outdoor air Indoor units or ducting (usually no hot water) £2,500
Exhaust air Warm air leaving the building Water-based heating, hot water or ventilation ducting Not yet a listed category

Air-source vs ground-source heat pumps: which is better?

Ground-source heat pumps have been widely used since the 1970s. They have an advantage: underground temperatures are more stable than winter air temperatures, which can help seasonal efficiency. But they need a lot of groundwork, including trenches, boreholes or a shared ground loop. For most existing houses, that means extra cost and disruption before the system can even start heating the property.

Colin Usher, low-carbon homes architect

"Air-source heat pumps are so good now that I don't think the extra expense of ground-source is terribly worthwhile in most situations. Twenty years ago, there were concerns about extracting enough heat from outside air for significant periods of the year. That's largely no longer the case."

Colin Usher, Retired architect and low energy house designer

When it comes to replacing a boiler with an air-to-water system, Colin says, "For most householders, what they want to do is take out a gas boiler and put in a heat pump. An air-source heat pump that does the same job as the gas boiler, putting hot water into the radiators, is a bit of a no-brainer."

He points out that switching an existing home from radiators to a warm-air distribution system can mean additional building work: "As soon as you start doing anything else, you're having to change more of the building's infrastructure."

There are some cases where ground-source can be considered. Colin explains, "For industrial and commercial situations, ground-source probably still makes sense. There are also situations where you can get almost geothermal levels of heat from the ground. In those circumstances, it could be worthwhile."

What is an exhaust air heat pump?

Exhaust air heat pumps (EAHPs) recover energy from warm, moist air being extracted from a building. Some transfer that heat to water for space heating or domestic hot water; others use it to warm supply air delivered through ventilation ducting. They can be housed indoors and may be combined with mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR), although MVHR on its own is not a heat pump. The available heat and the ventilation design must suit the building.

"It does involve having ducting running around your house," Colin points out. "It's probably much more workable in new build than in existing homes. A bungalow with accessible loft space might offer a practical retrofit route; a multi-storey house may not."

Colin says these caught on originally in the Nordic countries. "The Scandinavians were early adopters because their winters can be extremely cold."

One example Colin discussed was the Pichler PKOM4, an integrated exhaust air heat pump and ventilation unit used in highly insulated accommodation. "It's very much an everything-in-one-box kind of affair," he said. "It uses the mechanical ventilation heat recovery side of it to also do the heating."

Exhaust air heat pumps are not currently listed as a separate category under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme, and the Energy Saving Trust expects them to become eligible in future. If a grant matters to your decision, check the proposed system and installer against Ofgem's current requirements before you commit.

Can you have a heat pump in a flat?

Flats are a good example of Colin's insistence on matching the technology to the building. An existing flat may have nowhere suitable for an outdoor unit, limited space for a hot-water cylinder and no practical route for new ducting. "If you've got nowhere to put an air-source heat pump outside, then putting something inside might make more sense. But it could be that the sensible solution is to use a heat pump for the hot water and direct electricity for the heating."

Colin points to a colleague's low-energy new-build apartments as an example of keeping things simple. They use MVHR, dedicated heat-pump hot-water cylinders and ordinary wall-mounted electric radiators, rather than air-to-air heat pumps for space heating. For a different new-build design, integrated warm-air systems may make sense because, as Colin says, "You can build in all the ductwork paths right from the start."

For an existing electrically heated flat, Colin suggests that a more limited intervention might be sensible: "It might just use the Dimplex hot water cylinder with its own heat pump." The Dimplex Edel range uses a small heat pump to produce domestic hot water, leaving room heating unchanged. Before choosing that approach, compare the installation cost, available space, expected hot-water demand and electricity tariffs. It will not necessarily be the best option for every flat.

Will a heat pump work in an older house?

Our Heat Pump Ready series looks at improving a home's energy efficiency so a heat pump can be cheaper to run than a gas boiler. Older houses often lose more heat through poorly insulated walls and roofs, draughts and inefficient glazing. The heating system must replace that lost warmth, whether it is a boiler or a heat pump. Better insulation and draught-proofing can reduce the demand and help a heat pump operate at lower flow temperatures.

"It would be wise to start looking at upgrading insulation, particularly in the roof space," Colin says. "Sorting out draughts, possibly getting a few new windows" can also help. Where a property still has single glazing, secondary or double glazing may be worth considering. These improvements reduce the heating demand and can make it easier for a heat pump to run efficiently. Our guides to floor and loft insulation, draught proofing and windows and doors cover each step in more detail.

There are less glamorous obstacles, too. The old boiler may have occupied a cupboard that cannot accommodate a hot-water cylinder. New pipework may have to pass through kitchen units, and the outdoor unit needs a suitable electrical connection.

Do you need new radiators for a heat pump?

Not always. Heat pumps often work best with lower-temperature water than a traditional boiler, so some radiators need more surface area to give out enough heat.

Colin says, "Quite often, houses had large radiators because they were using relatively inefficient gas central heating systems. Then they changed to condensing boilers and those radiators were effectively oversized. When they move to a heat pump, they may find the radiators are already the right size."

Colin gives the example of a house in Edinburgh, where some radiators were changed rather than replacing them all. The occupants' preferred indoor temperatures mattered: they were content with cooler rooms generally but wanted comfortable living areas where they spent time sitting still.

How much bigger do heat pump radiators need to be?

There is no credible answer without calculating each room's heat loss and checking the radiator's output at the proposed flow temperature. Colin is equally unwilling to prescribe a universal flow temperature. "I think that's got to be down to the designer," he said. The installer should explain the calculations, not rely on a blanket claim that every radiator must be doubled in size, for example.

What size heat pump do I need?

The number of bedrooms alone does not tell an installer the building's heat loss. Wall and roof insulation, glazing, air leakage, room sizes and the winter design temperature all affect the result.

The installer should calculate heat loss room by room and select a heat pump that can meet the demand under the relevant conditions. That assessment should also establish which radiators or underfloor heating circuits need changing. A system that is too small may struggle on the coldest days; one that is unnecessarily large can cost more and may cycle inefficiently.

Colin repeatedly returned to how the occupants actually live. A family happy with cooler bedrooms but a warmer sitting room needs a different emitter specification from one wanting every room at the same temperature. That is why the homeowner should see the design assumptions before signing off the equipment.

What to ask your heat pump installer

First, Colin suggests: "Can I talk to one of your satisfied clients?" A reference from a comparable property is more useful than a generic promise that the installation will be straightforward.

He continues, "The next question would be what they think needs to be done to the house, and where they think they're going to put the hot-water cylinder. Those are important practical questions."

Questions to ask before you sign

  • Can I talk to one of your satisfied clients with a similar property?
  • What do you think needs to be done to the house first?
  • Where will the hot-water cylinder go, and how will the new pipework run?
  • How will you get the electrical supply to the heat pump?
  • Can I see the room-by-room heat loss calculations and the design assumptions?

As to any red flags?

Colin Usher, low-carbon homes architect

"If an installer says, 'Oh yes, this is easy, we won't have to change anything,' I wouldn't be very happy. If they make it sound too easy, that's a warning sign, because it usually isn't that simple."

Colin Usher, Retired architect and low energy house designer

When it came to fitting a heat pump in his elderly sister's home, he explained, "The designer working on my sister's house has been quite clear that where we wanted to put the hot-water cylinder isn't possible. We're going to have to get underneath the kitchen units to run the pipework. Those are the practical problems you need somebody to identify: where the new pipes go, how you get everything in the right place and how you get the electrical supply to the heat pump. People who raise practical concerns are the people you really want to be talking to."

A final tip is not to overcomplicate the system. A wireless connection coordinating Colin's own inverter, battery and electricity meter has failed, leaving his carefully optimised energy setup temporarily unable to behave as intended. "If you overcomplicate it, it can become a bit of a mess," he said. "A good design should remain understandable and serviceable when a component fails."

Can you get a heat pump just for hot water?

Yes. A dedicated heat-pump cylinder can heat domestic hot water without replacing the room-heating system. Colin sees a possible role for these units in electrically heated flats and other properties where a full heating retrofit would be disproportionate. But the purchase price, hot-water demand, installation constraints and electricity tariff all matter.

Colin has first-hand experience of how a heat pump works over the longer term. His own four-bedroom home has a conventional air-to-water heat pump serving underfloor heating and a separate hot-water cylinder of approximately 300 litres. "The equipment is probably about fourteen and a half years old now," he says. Most of the time only two people live there, although hot-water demand rises when guests stay. The cylinder is in the middle of the house, so some of the heat it loses in winter contributes to warming the building.

Living with the system for nearly 15 years has also given Colin time to adjust how he uses it. "Over time I've optimised things so that the hot water heats during the night," he explains. He schedules an extra boost after lunch if needed, when solar generation may be available. In another property, a 220-litre cylinder will soon face the demands of a larger family. Colin has installed a shower wastewater heat-recovery unit there and is waiting to see whether changes to shower routines or additional hot-water capacity are needed.

Frequently asked questions

Which type of heat pump is most efficient?

Ground-source can deliver high seasonal efficiency because ground temperatures are relatively stable. But Colin's preference for many ordinary UK homes is a correctly designed air-to-water system, where the simpler installation may outweigh any efficiency advantage from ground-source.

Is an air-to-air heat pump worth it?

It may be, particularly where rooms can be heated directly and cooling is also useful. But it generally does not provide domestic hot water. Colin cautions that retrofitting a different heat-distribution system may introduce more building work than a conventional air-to-water replacement.

Can I get a grant for a heat pump?

The Boiler Upgrade Scheme provides grants for eligible installations in England and Wales. Qualifying air-to-water and ground-source heat pumps generally receive £7,500, while qualifying air-to-air systems receive £2,500. Until 31 March 2027, the grant rises to £9,000 for eligible off-gas-grid homes replacing oil or LPG heating with an air-to-water or ground-source system. Exhaust air heat pumps are not currently listed as a separate category, and fossil-fuel hybrid systems are excluded. The installer and proposed equipment must meet Ofgem's requirements.

Which heat pump should you choose?

Colin's experience suggests that there is no single right answer. He has lived with an air-to-water heat pump for nearly 15 years, but his work on flats and low-energy buildings shows why a different property may need a different solution. Most homes replacing a boiler and retaining radiators will start by considering air-to-water. An integrated warm-air system may suit a carefully designed new build, while a flat could benefit from a dedicated heat-pump hot-water cylinder without changing its space heating.

The lesson from Colin is to favour a system that suits the building rather than the most elaborate technology available. Find an installer who understands the property, can explain the compromises and has the experience to make the installation work in practice. Then compare the electricity tariffs available to you before deciding what it will cost to run.

Getting your home ready for a heat pump

Start with 1. How to Make Your Home Heat Pump Ready, then work through 2. Assessing your home for heat pumps. Whatever you decide about heating, make sure you are on the right energy tariff.

Compare energy prices

Written by Richard Shrubb with Colin Usher, low-carbon homes architect. Last updated: 18 November 2026.

Never miss out on energy savings!

Want to be amongst the first to be notified when more competitive energy tariffs become available? Enter your email address here...

We won't spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Our energy expert

Compare. Switch. Save. Join millions of homes switching with the UK energy experts.

You may also be interested in:


Ofgem Confidence Code
Fully accredited by Ofgem since 2003